Adults Only

Something the wife and I have talked about many times (as most long-term couples do), is about the future and the potential of having kids.

From the beginning, we always agreed that we wouldn’t want more than 2 if it’s up to us, and that perhaps we might count our blessings and stop with one happy and healthy child. But it was always a talk for the future, never anything imminent that we wanted soon.

And that’s still our status quo. In the past year or so the language has shifted to “if” and not “when” as it comes to children, as we recognize that we still haven’t decided if it’s right for us, and even if we do want it, we know other couples that have struggled to conceive. But it’s still something we communicate about.

I feel certain though that once we have kids, if we choose to, anything that we haven’t already explored will be off the table. And I don’t want to expect or hope that maybe we could try new things after parenthood begins, because one, I don’t believe that would happen, and two, that would be unfair to our child.

If we have a child, our focus about changing our lifestyle needs to be about building a supportive and loving family system for the child, not worrying as much about ourselves. So I don’t want to enter a delusion for a decade or two or and have this unrealistic expectation hanging over us for years and years and years about when will this happen? We do we want to try something?

I know that expanding/opening our relationship can be fraught with peril and pain at times, and that’s likely not something we’d want to expose our family with children to. But this also isn’t a hostage situation, that I absolutely will not agree to children until we explore poly. I just feel very aware that this is a part of who I am and how I feel, and that if kids come first that precludes poly, so if that’s the direction we go down (with kids) then I will be very aware that I am agreeing to a number of other decisions and finalities as well. And if I say that it’s what I want too and I’m on board with her, then I have to be when I say that. And I’ll have to mean it.

Wait for It

Another song.

The song: “Wait For It”

Selected lyrics:
Love doesn’t discriminate
between the sinners and the saints,
it takes and it takes and it takes.

And we keep loving anyway
We laugh and we cry
and we break
and we make our mistakes.

And if there’s a reason I’m by her side
when so many have tried
then I’m willing to wait for it.
I’m willing to wait for it.

I am the one thing in life I can control
I am inimitable
I am an original.

I’m not falling behind or running late
I’m not standing still,
I am lying in wait.

———-

I’ve listened to this about 20 times in a row at the moment, and it’s still on repeat. This might be my night.

All I can control is myself. More and more I’m internalizing that. It’s affording me calm and strength. It puts me back in control of my life. I can’t help who and how I feel love. I can control my actions, but the feelings will be real whether I address them or not.

Monogamy By Default

Until very recently, monogamy was all I expected of myself, the only future I could foresee. It was the only future I thought I wanted, because I didn’t know I could have anything else.

I’m not one who fails for confidence, but I have always struggled with agency. Lots of things that are very normal, very common things in life seem like they’re something that everyone else does, but not me. In college, my roommates went to a pet shop to get a hamster for our apartment. I loved the little girl and eventually took ownership of her, and was so glad to have her. 

Honestly, it never occurred to me that I could just go get a pet if I wanted one. I was 20, and it wasn’t something I would’ve done. It just didn’t occur to be something I could do.

The same things happened to me when I rented my first apartment on my own and bought my first car. Both times, it was as if I was having an out of body experience. It couldn’t be me that was taking this action, that’s not what happens to me.

It’s hard to explain, but as I said, it mostly boils down to a sense of agency, believing (or not) that I control my actions and choose what happens in my life.

I’ve gotten better at this, I feel like I’m improving. I suppose I found a sense of agency, considering I summoned the strength to tell my wife that I wanted more than our relationship as it was, that there was something more I felt I needed. Even though one of my biggest fears is losing her, I had to push through that to be honest with who I am and what I think I need to be happy.

Fear Versus Strength

For seven years it was not talking about it out of fear. It was something beyond my control, something oppressing me, and it hurt my buy-in with my relationship. For a long time I didn’t even think that I was poly, I just thought that “well yes, of course, who wouldn’t find the idea fascinating and alluring?” Then I realized not everyone does. And further still I realized that this wasn’t a hypothetical about feeling inclined towards poly, that in fact, I actually was interested.

But right now, after having come out to my spouse, I’m making the decision to keep quiet, to work on myself, to learn and evaluate. Because I recognize that now isn’t the time, and that I want to support my wife. By not putting this issue on her at the moment and instead focusing together with her on more immediate matters, I am supporting her. And it makes me feel stronger, like I have a choice in my life.

That’s not to say that I never want to address all of this and try to sort it out; but it’s become something I can control, not something I am running from.

That a-ha Moment

Listening to the first episode of “Life on the Swingset,” and they’re doing a beginners episode for dummies.

And yes, they are talking about the “a-ha moment,” when you realized you were different.

“At some point, you kind of have to stop saying ‘you’re a bad person’ and just accept you feel a certain way.”

I’ve never felt like I was the best partner, the best spouse, but I’ve always approached my relationship from a place of love and commitment. And I know that culture and people talk about crushes (that person in class, that co-worker) and how innocent it is and meaningless and then it’s just gone. But that wasn’t me.

Why does this person stay lodged in my head? Why does it feel this intense? I still love my partner right? Ok, I do. But then why do I still feel like this? Why is this more than just a crush?

I’ve grappled with these thoughts for forever. I assumed that everyone actually felt like this, it’s just something that is best left undiscussed, a collective, unspoken denial about the way we all feel. After all, I was still committed to my one relationship, just like everyone else, so I must be normal like everyone else. Right?

I don’t know when my actual “a-ha moment” was. There isn’t some transgression that cemented it for me. There isn’t some heartbreak or silent pain that forced me to confront it. Rather, it was something that just very slowly, (very, very slowly) eeked it’s way into my consciousness. And eventually I had to acknowledge its inevitablility, this was who I was. This is who I am.

Would That Be Enough?

As I’m reading, learning, and studying everything about how I feel and what I want, I’ve started to connect and process my thoughts through several forms of media.

One of the ways I’ve always regulated my emotions was through music, and in the past few days I’ve started to collect some songs that put me in a place, or frame my mindset.

The song: “That Would Be Enough”

https://open.spotify.com/track/6oF8ueLn5hIl4PRp17sxW6​

Selected Lyrics:

Look at where you are
Look at where you started
The fact that you’re alive is a miracle
Just stay alive, that would be enough

And if this child
Shares a fraction of your smile
Or a fragment of your mind, look out world!
That would be enough

I don’t pretend to know
The challenges you’re facing
The worlds you keep erasing and creating in your mind

But I’m not afraid
I know who I married
So long as you come home at the end of the day
That would be enough

We don’t need a legacy
We don’t need money
If I could grant you peace of mind
If you could let me inside your heart…

Oh, let me be a part of the narrative
In the story they will write someday
Let this moment be the first chapter:
Where you decide to stay

And I could be enough
And we could be enough
That would be enough

———-

Oof, I mean, did you read that? This song just guts me every time. I can hear my wife singing this to me, pleading with me to love her in the way she loves me.

And I want this love too. I want her and I against the world, ready to face whatever life throws at us together. In a lot of ways, I wish that that was all I felt, that it was just as simple as that. But it never really has been.

“Peace of mind,” that’s the part that really sticks with me. That it’s not anything she’s failing to do, it’s not that our relationship isn’t strong. It’s that I don’t have that peace of mind. I don’t know if I ever will, because I don’t know if I ever have. It would be so much simpler to press this all down, to shut it out, and to just focus on the good things I have and live the life in front of me. But will that lead to peace of mind? I don’t believe so.

I think there will always be regret, wondering, questioning, longing. I don’t know if exploring poly or being in an open relationship changes any of this, but it might. It seems like it could.

But it’s also so, so damn selfish. My wife is mono, and just wants love and devotion, in the same way she loves me and is devoted to me. And that’s not a tall ask. And it’s what I promised her, when we began, when I proposed, when we we’d.

How I Got to Today (or, The Supreme Influence of Loveline, Dan Savage, and Reddit)

Here I am as I start this. Quick intro: I’m 30, a white male, and married. The wife and I have been together since early in college, and have been married now for five years.

We’re a great couple. Or, more accurately, we are great for each other. From the moment I met her, she has been unyieldingly caring, loving, alluring, sexy, giving, and kind. I don’t know how I ended up with someone like her, other than I took a shot and she somehow liked me too.

In our 11 years, we have had countless lifelong moments; the kind of events and memories that stay with you forever. We fell for each other, found love with each other, and then forged a life together. But while this was happening, we weren’t as unified as it seemed.

As it turns out, during the years we were engaged, I had emotionally and sexually withdrawn from her. In my mind, our relationship was cruising along, and an entire life laid ahead on the horizon for us. I thought we were a fortunate couple, that we found each other and had what we needed and could build the next 70 years together side by side.

Flash forward four years later, we’re married and in a new city. I was feeling horny but it didn’t seem like it was going to happen between us that night. So, while she was tired and turned in to bed, I went to the living room to masturbate and relieve the situation.

She came out, saw me, reacted, and things went from there. A long night followed, and what it all stemmed from was a lot deeper than what I was doing that night in the living room.

It turns out that I had not been sexually satisfying her for the past four years. Sex between us had been extremely limited, and when it happened, it was centered around my desires and intent. What had been a firy and fun sex life in the first three years died out when we had moved in together, and she had been silently suffering ever since, assuming she had done something horribly wrong to cause the turn of events.

In actuality though, I had been the one to change, but I didn’t know it at the time, and it was something that still took me years more to understand. I had drawn away and retreated within myself, and relied on porn and imagination and masturbation instead of connecting with the real, loving partner right there in front of me. I was still in love, we still shared so many moments, but in the bedroom I had left her.

Once she caught me and confronted me, things came to the fore. In the years since, we have gotten better, in fits and spurts. We communicate much more than we had, and I am entirely more aware of what is happening between us when it comes to sex than I had been in the worst times.

Things are still hard though, I still have regressions and roadblocks that keep me from being the husband to her that we both want me to be. But then there are times when everything clicks, when we’re entirely connected, and the sex blows us away, and we’re clutching to each other in the afterglow and grinning like damned fools, that we know that it’s still there between us.

I’ve made progress, and I’ve been seeing a therapist for several months now, and it really is helping me to have a space to talk through things and really sort myself out. There is no end game for the therapy, I went in with the intention of wanting to become a better partner for my wife, and to find the tools to handle myself better. These things are happening, but I will always have to be working at it to get to where I hope to be.

A large part of the reason I finally sought therapy was because in the weeks before my first session I finally admitted to myself that I was polyamorous.

It was something I had known for the past seven years, but had not been willing to admit to even myself. It is why I withdrew. It was why I locked myself into my own world of porn and denial. It was why I was selfish. I had started to find this about myself, but felt trapped and scared of it, by the strangeness of it, the OTHERNESS of it. I was a straight, educated white male from a good family and I had a long term, committed relationship with a perfect woman. There was nothing in my life that spoke to otherness. There was nothing about me that was subject to judgment or criticism by others. I was standard and average. I was happy.

So I briefly explored the most superficial aspects of what it meant to be poly, and then I locked it away. That wasn’t my life. That wouldn’t be my life. That isn’t who I am.

And I thought that it was done. We seemed happy. We got married. We started the rest of our life together. And then it fell apart that night. And then I woke up to who I really had been. And I cried when I realized what I had done to my wife. And I cried that she stood with me all this time, that she could love me that much, that she could be that patient and forgiving.

And so I tried to be better. And sometimes I was. Maybe most of the time I was. But we kept having setbacks, things still couldn’t come easy for us when we knew it just should. But not for us. And I had thought about therapy. I had put out a feeler and researched a few providers. But as soon as an obstacle came up, I shrunk back away.

Cut to this spring. Another setback. More pain. More failure. And I knew that it was now or never. I knew that I could never give all of myself to her, I could never be who I am, if I wasn’t entirely and openly honest right then. So I told her. My secret of seven years. My secret that terrified me. My secret that could cost me my marriage. But I had no more choices, no other way out.

There are no words for it all. Though she heard some of the most shocking news of her life, my wife didn’t make it about her. She wasn’t angry, she wasn’t argumentative. She listened, she heard me, she asked me careful and measured questions. And she let me talk. She let me explain anything that I felt needed to be said. And then she let it all sink in.

And that was the moment it began, the moment that someone else knew my secret. And that was when I didn’t have to carry my secret every day, I didn’t have to internalize the shame and the longing. It was out into the world, it was known to the most important person in my life.

So that’s how it began. Nothing fun, nothing sexy, nothing scandalous. Just one man scared that the life he knew was ending and that there was no way forward but to confront his reality. And one woman that heard him, loved him, and stayed by his side that night.

This is the start of my journey, of figuring out who I really am. I needed a space to record my thoughts, to sort myself out. For those who wish to participate with me, you’re welcome to join in. Hopefully something I stumble across might help someone else too. And having a friend to lean on never hurt either.